The Protein Bar

In the United States and Canada, sulfites are not allowed on red meat. Sodium bisulfite does such a good job of color fixing, sulfited ground beef can be rotten and you can’t tell by looking at it. For safety and because vitamins can be affected, the FDA has an absolute prohibition against sulfites in meat.  However, the rule doesn’t apply to other ingredients that may be mixed into the meat. For instance, sausage may legally contain corn syrup, molasses, or wine. In other parts of the world ( especially in the UK and Australia ), sulfite preservatives are allowed in ground beef and sausages. So, watch out when you are traveling.

SharkFish is another story. Sulfites are an allowed preservative for fish all around the world. Theoretically, in American stores, sulfited fish must carry a warning somewhere near the fish display, but I’ve never seen one. And, a sulfited fish has bitten me more than a few times, especially swordfish. On the other hand, I have had good luck with salmon either from the supermarket or in restaraunts. Whether declared or not, ocean shrimp are almost always preserved with sulfite to prevent a black spotting fungus. Farmed shrimp have an additional twist; they are fed meal containing sulfite preservatives. Restaurants can further complicate matters by deep frying shrimp in a common vat with vegetables. The shrimp sulfites leak into the oil and contaminate otherwise clean vegetables. At my house, I substitute fresh avocado slices for shrimp and make a "shrimpless" cocktail. But, beware of cocktail sauces which contain preserved horseradish, wine and lemon juice concentrate. I mix up my own sauce using organic ketchup, rice vinegar, fresh lemons and refrigerated horseradish colored with beet juice.

Gelatin is pure protein processed to promote the gelling of liquids. In other words, Jell-O. Most of the gelatin produced in the United States is made from pigskin, although cattle hide and bones are also used. The first step in making gelatin is a softening soak in sulfur dioxide and water. Why are we not surprised? Gelatin is used in many foods to build body and improve texture. Lowfat yogurts use lots of gelatin to make up for the missing milkfat. It is usually quite difficult to estimate the amount of gelatin in a food by just reading the label. However, it is quite easy to look at the table below which gives recommended percentages of gelatin for various types of foods. Gelatin typically has an effective sulfur oxide concentration of 45 ppm.  An alternative to gelatin is fruit pectin.  In the past, some forms of pectin were preserved with sulfites; however, today all forms of pectin are sulfite free.

Gelatin Table

Food Using Gelatin % Gelatin Serving Gelatin (g) SOx (ug)
         
Aspic salads 15 % cup 9.0 grams 405 ug
Gelled meats 3.0 2 ounce 1.7 grams 76
Gummy Worms 3.0 5 pieces 1.1 grams 50
Low Fat Spreads 2.0 1 Tbs 0.3 grams 14
Gelatin Dessert 1.5 cup 1.8 grams 81
Icing and Frosting 1.0 2 Tbs 0.3 grams 14
Syrups 1.0 cup 0.6 grams 27
Yogurt 0.5 1 cup 1.1 grams 50
Sauces and Gravies 0.5 cup 0.3 grams 14


I was quite surprised to discover that cheese contains sulfites. In hindsight, I have had some problems with Italian dishes like ravioli but never suspected the cheese. Then I ran into a very tasty white cheddar that clearly caused headaches. The nice folks in the dairy department at UC Davis told me that all cheeses contain low levels of sulfite created naturally during the aging process. But they did not have any numbers to pin things down. So, I had to add cheese to my list of sulfured ingredients and run some experiments to determine concentrations.

Cheese

Most cheese is made using the same basic steps developed by our forefathers 5,000 years ago. Milk is separated into solid curds and liquid whey by adding a little acid and enzyme borrowed from a cow’s tummy. As the mixture is pressed, salt is added, the whey is drained and the curds become more firm. The compacted curds are left to age and bacteria sharpens the flavor. Cheese may be categorized as fresh, soft, hard and dry. Fresh cheeses are not aged. Soft cheeses are aged but remain creamy either naturally or by processing. Hard cheeses include cheddar, jack, mozzarella, swiss and gouda. Dry cheeses are strongly aged with very low moisture like parmesan and dry jack.  I have included sour cream in the table because of its similarity to fresh cheeses.  ( Note that regular plain yogurt is not included in the table because it is very low in sulfites if it is pure without corn starch and gelatin. Plain yogurt is a good substitute for sour cream if you are very sensitive to sulfites like me. Also, kefir cheese is actually a form of yogurt and a good substitute for cream cheese if you are watching your sulfites. On the other hand, high protein Greek yogurt is not as good since the sulfites rise as it is concentrated during processing. I find Greek yogurt to have about the same level of effective sulfur oxide as cottage cheese. )

Common Cheese Table

Class Cheese Age SOx
Code Water Prot Fat
               
Fresh Cottage, lowfat Cottage 0.5 ppm CHC 82 % 12 % 1 %
  Queso Fresco Fresh 1.0 CHF 42 21 21
  Ricotta Fresh 1.1 CHF 74 11 8
Soft Cream Cheese Fresh 1.4 CHF 54 8 35
  Sour Cream Fresh 1.2 CHF 71 3 21
  American Mild 1.9 CHM 39 22 31
Hard Cheddar, mild Mild 2.0 CHM 37 25 33
  Cheddar, sharp Sharp 2.5 CHS 37 25 33
  Cheddar, white Extra 4.0 CHX 37 25 33
  Monterey Jack Fresh 1.5 CHF 41 24 30
  Mozzarella Mild 2.1 CHM 9 27 17
  Roquefort Sharp 3.2 CHS 42 21 29
  Swiss Cheese Mild 2.1 CHM 37 28 27
Dry Parmesan Extra 5.5 CHX 18 42 30


So, how do we estimate the sulfites? Since there are hundreds of different cheeses made all over the world in thousands of factories and farms, we must make some generalizations. First, the concentrations listed in the SOx column are the values determined from my headache tests on common brands found in a California supermarket. If you sort the data, five groups may be loosely related to cheese age: Cottage, Fresh, Mild, Sharp and Extra Sharp. Then, each group can be assigned a three letter SOx code. Some cheeses will be typically in only one of these groups while others may be represented in several. For instance, cheddar can be mild (aged 2 months), sharp (aged 6-9 months) and extra sharp (aged 1 year or more). If the exact type or age of a cheese is not specified on the ingredient label, "mild" would be a good guess, since mild cheeses are generally less expensive. The six age groups are summarized in the table below. For each group, a representative cheese is used as an example for a typical serving size and resulting amount of effective sulfur oxide. As usual, the typical serving sizes are designed for dieting midgets. My typical servings are larger and sometimes result in a headache.

Basic Cheese Groups

Age Code SOx
Example Serving Size SOx ug
           
Cottage CHC 0.5 ppm Cottage cup (113 g) 56 ug
Fresh CHF 1.2 Sour Cream 2 Tbs (30 g) 36
Mild CHM 2.0 American 1 slice (21 g) 42
Sharp CHS 3.0 Sharp Cheddar 1 inch cube (28 g) 84
Extra CHX 5.0 Parmesan 2 teaspoons (5 g) 25


Well, if cheese can have sulfites, maybe we should look more closely at other flavorful foods. A couple of interesting candidates might be sourdough bread and eggs. Sourdough bread is made using a starter yeast that is aged. Thinking this might affect bread much as aging affects cheese, I ate four slices of DiCarlo Extra Sourdough Bread. Guess what, no headache. If sourdough bread has any sulfur oxide, it must be under ppm. Bread lovers may breathe a sigh of relief.

What about eggs? If you’ve ever smelled a rotten egg, you know sulfur is in there somewhere. EggSo, I tested eggs. No, I didn’t suck them out of the shell. I’m very cultured. I smashed them into a pan and scrambled them. A typical egg without the shell weighs about 50 grams. It takes 3 scrambled eggs to give me a headache. However, if the eggs are prepared over easy, only 2 eggs are required for a headache. Apparently, some of the sulfites are lost or converted during the cooking process. Since scrambling exposes more of the egg to heat and atmospheric oxygen, scrambled eggs wind up with a slightly lower sulfite concentration. Averaging over various methods of preparation, the effective sulfur oxide concentration of eggs is about 1.0 ppm. This is a low value if eggs are just another ingredient in a recipe, but as the main course in a hearty breakfast, the total amount of sulfur might be significant.

Before my tests, I didn't suspect that eggs were a problem. It takes over 24 hours for the headache to appear, about the same delay as starch. Apparently, whenever I woke up with an egg headache, I suspected the previous night’s dinner, not the previous day’s breakfast. I’m wiser now, but also a bit sadder. What am I to do; I really like omelets, especially cheese omelets. If I stop feeling sorry for myself long enough to be creative, eggs and cheese are not much of a problem. For instance, I can have an omelet made with one egg, a little fresh cheese (like Queso Fresco Mexican cheese) and lots of vegetables. I can have baked potatoes topped with butter and plain yogurt (no starch, no gelatin and not Greek) instead of sour cream. And, cheeseburgers can be made with a spoonful of kefir chesse.  I know it sounds a little weird and such a diet does make you feel like burning incense and chanting a mantra. But, what's a poor boy to do?

Return to the Book Index

Rybett Controls

Advance to Next Chapter